Skip to content
Steady Review

Two and a Half Decades Back, a Grand PS2 Flop Set the Stage for Kingdom Hearts

Picture SquareSoft trying to create a Yakuza-style game half a decade before Sega released theirs—a project mixing brawler combat with RPG elements and splashy cinematics. Now consider this undertaking was helmed by some of the industry's most respected creative minds. Finally, envision the final product falling short than the promise of its team. This title is The Bouncer, created by DreamFactory and released in the US in early 2001, shortly after the launch of the PlayStation 2.

Indeed, the two giants had a brief alliance in the 1990s and early '00s. It's not pleasant to recall it. It feels like finding out your parent used to date your employer.

The Story of an Ambitious Flop

The Bouncer centers on three bartenders—Sion, Kou, and Volt—who must rescue their kidnapped friend Dominique from the sinister Mikado Corporation. The action unfolds in the metropolis of Edge, a location with a neon-lit urban edge that brings to mind the aesthetics of Final Fantasy 7’s Wall Market and Star Wars’s Coruscant lower levels.

A Stellar Directorial Duo

The game boasted two helmers, each with stellar credits. Takashi Tokita, known for Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy 4, co-directed. Seichii Ichii, who helped design Virtua Fighter and was game director for the first two Tekken titles. Given this pedigree, one would expect the combat to be pretty solid.

Welp, it turns out that the fighting might be the worst aspect. The issues stemmed from a unforgiving control scheme and over-the-top ragdoll physics that turned every defeated enemy into a flailing tube-man. Stranger still, each level was extremely brief, frequently lasting less than a minute. Cutscenes made up nearly two-thirds of the game's roughly 2-hour runtime, meaning skipping them could slash the total playtime to a just 30 to 45 minutes.

"This game manages to look good," noted one pithy critic, "but don't let that fool you into believing that it's very fun."

Style Over Substance

While the gameplay wasn't satisfying, critics agreed that The Bouncer possessed a unique and eye-catching aesthetic. The cutscenes represented a noticeable step up from the PlayStation 1 era. Adding to this, the characters were designed by the famed artist of Final Fantasy 7 fame, showcasing some truly wild Y2K fashions.

  • Elaborate body art covered the chest and forehead of one character.
  • The group featured a plethora of exposed male torso, long coats, chunky footwear, and chunky chain necklaces.
  • The villainous foes wore distinctive onesies with a conspicuous whale tail on the rear.

Most eye-catching of all was Sion, who sports a close similarity to future hero the keyblade wielder. Though one is more mature, their design is virtually identical: untamed brown hair, a red, short-sleeved hoodie, voluminous pants, and a accessory chain. Their clothing boasts a distinctive red and blue with pops of gold.

The Confirmed Connection

In a 2003 conversation with artist Yoji Shinkawa, Nomura confirmed this resemblance was entirely intentional. "Since all the other characters are not Square characters, I wanted the protagonist's look to be a sort of 'grand compilation' of all the designs I'd created up to that point," he said. "Therefore he resembles a lot of characters: there's a bit of Cloud, a bit of Tidus, some Sion too. I was very intent on that."

An Enduring Legacy

The Bouncer may not have created its own franchise, but its influence endured…in an indirect way. A quarter century on, Sora has become one of the most beloved figures ever, and the prospect of Kingdom Hearts 4 still generate excitement globally. And it all might have unfolded in another way if it weren't for Sion. One can only wish that the next chapter reintroduces those memorable whale tails, whenever it finally launches.

Written by

Christopher Marsh

Elara Vance is a tech journalist and digital strategist with over a decade of experience covering emerging technologies and consumer electronics.

Steady Review

Type to search articles.